fbpx

2018 NBA Rookie of the Year Race

2018 NBA Rookie of the Year Race

Written by Logan Karels (@Karels23)

Stats & Team Records

Donovan Mitchell and Ben Simmons — these are the two young players who were frontrunners for the honor of the Rookie of the Year (RotY) award. First, we will take a look at their regular season statistics.

Donovan Mitchell:  20.5 PPG |3.7 RPG | 3.7 APG | 1.5 SPG

Ben Simmons: 15.8 PPG|8.1 RPG |8.2 APG | 1.7 SPG 

Mitchell is obviously more of a scorer and shooter than Simmons is, but you have to look at what else Simmons does for the Sixers. As a point guard, he often brings up the ball and running parts of the offense, all while distributing and getting his teammates involved.

Simmons helped lead his team to a 52-30 record, taking the third seed in the Eastern Conference. On the other side, Mitchell led his team to a 48-34 record, taking the fifth seed in the West. It can be argued Mitchell had the more impressive season due to his team being in the tougher Western Conference. Not to discredit the Sixers spectacular turnaround from the previous year with an impressive 24-game improvement (from 28 games in 2016-17 to 52 last year). It would appear “Trusting the Process” has indeed worked out in their favor. It’s obvious they will continue their upward trajectory in the upcoming seasons with all the young talent on the roster. Before this year, Philadelphia would never have been thought of a landing spot for LeBron. However, after their turnaround season, things are looking up.

Player Comparisons

As great as Ben Simmons is; he has weaknesses — as all rookies do. Obviously, the most notable flaw would be his shooting ability. Mitchell certainly has the edge here despite Simmons’ raw higher field goal percentage. You have to take that with a grain of salt as most of Simmons’ shot attempts come from inside the paint while driving to the basket due to his weak shooting ability. Obviously, this translates to Simmons’ free throw shooting ability as well. It’s also below average: 56% compared to Mitchell’s 80.5% on the season. Mitchell is already drawing comparisons to Dwyane Wade which is an honor in itself, Wade being the future Hall-of-Famer he is. The only significant difference is that Mitchell is a stronger shooter than Wade was at that age. Of course, Mitchell has some serious work to do to live up to Wade’s reputation in the league.

Both of these rookies had outstanding seasons and many memorable moments it’s hard to pick the best ones. One could go on forever about how talented these two rookies really are. What Mitchell did to lead his team in his rookie season was an incredible thing to behold. The fact is that he was playing in the Western Conference as well. Simmons also helped to lead his team to the playoffs this year. Simmons was even drawing some comparisons as a “mini-LeBron” due to them being such a freight train in transition with nearly unparalleled court vision as playmakers.  That comparison is a quite a stretch since Simmons has only played 81 games while LeBron has played 1143 regular season games. We’ll revisit when Simmons has developed further and is in his prime. There may be some similarities in the future.

Some pundits thought there should have been a co-rookie of the year award just like Jason Kidd and Grant Hill in 1994-95.

Closing Thoughts

While Simmons won the Rookie of the Year award over Mitchell, Jayson Tatum deserves an honorable mention in the race for ROTY. Tatum really stepped up amidst a plethora of injuries that plagued the resilient Boston Celtic team led by Brad Stevens. With all this taken into account, I thought Mitchell should have won. What he has done to lead the team in the Western conference was tough and he deserves to be recognized for it. This doesn’t take away from Simmons’ season at all though. He still had a very impressive rookie campaign. It was great to watch all the leagues’ young rookies compete this year and will be even better watching them improve in the seasons to come. Given all the stats and accolades these two players accumulated during this past season, I believe that Mitchell should have won ROTY, but something was telling me that Simmons was going to be taking home the hardware instead.